| Jeremy's Team | Shawn's Team | Devin's Team | Brad's Team | Dave's Team | Rick's Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cam Newton QB - CAR | Russell Wilson QB - SEA | Antonio Brown WR - PIT | David Johnson RB - ARI | Alex Smith QB - KC | Ben Roethlisberger QB - PIT |
| 2 | DeAndre Hopkins WR - HOU | Doug Baldwin WR - SEA | James White RB - NE | Tom Brady QB - NE | Demaryius Thomas WR - DEN | Rob Gronkowski TE - NE |
| 3 | Adrian Peterson RB - MIN | Marshawn Lynch RB - SEA | Jonathan Stewart RB - CAR | Emmanuel Sanders WR - DEN | Charcandrick West RB - KC | Markus Wheaton WR - PIT |
| 4 | Greg Olsen TE - CAR | A.J. Green WR - CIN | Jordan Reed TE - WAS | Jeremy Hill RB - CIN | Travis Kelce TE - KC | Tyler Lockett WR - SEA |
| 5 | DeAngelo Williams RB - PIT | C.J. Anderson RB - DEN | Julian Edelman WR - NE | Jeremy Maclin WR - KC | Albert Wilson WR - KC | Spencer Ware RB - KC |
| 6 | Stephen Gostkowski K - NE | Cincinnati Bengals DST - CIN | Pittsburgh Steelers DST - PIT | Arizona Cardinals DST - ARI | Chris Polk RB - HOU | Seattle Seahawks DST - SEA |
| 7 | Kansas City Chiefs DST - KC | Nick Novak K - HOU | Steven Hauschka K - SEA | Chris Boswell K - PIT | Cairo Santos K - KC | Graham Gano K - CAR |
| 8 | Devin Funchess WR - CAR | Tyler Eifert TE - CIN | Carson Palmer QB - ARI | Heath Miller TE - PIT | Carolina Panthers DST - CAR | Ronnie Hillman RB - DEN |